Kaitlin wrote:I don't think any player should be expected to react or their character feel in a prescribed way but aren't you just as guilty in expecting them to respond to your roleplay or offer you roleplay in a certain way? You have established that you expected them to somehow do more in RP to gain the response that would be normal for a gorean slave. Some may choose to move on which would seem a good thing for all involved.
*sighs* I did not said I expect them to do anything. I said I expect them to do soemthing IF they want me to act in a certain way, completely different story. Other then hat I am acting of course like a Gorean slave. Again, it is about feelings, reactions, that are not coming with a simple training. I hope I said it this time more clear.
Kaitlin wrote:As for the comparison to Elinor her issue was pretty simple...she needed to be branded properly and fucked. After that point she was very clearly a slave even if she had a rather interesting journey up until that point. It would be an interesting story to play out but I still struggle to see how it dictates different treatment.
Again, it does not dictate a different treatment. Only when you want something, like Rask wanted her to give in and gave her what turned her into a slave for him. And that is exactly what I talk about all the time. You do not give, you do not receive. I give as much of my part, as I am able to, then it is the Frees part to answer to it and give his/hers part. That is what I call roleplay
Kaitlin wrote:Just to clarify, my reply wasn't intended to state that you were not playing your role in a BTB fashion or you were not experienced since my comment on barbarian play was very general. I just failed to understand how random Masters would be expected to contribute to your slave training other than just treating you as a slave.
See above, WHEN random Masters expect me to act in a certain way, that my role is not able to, due to the circumstances I was not broken in, trained, whatever... THEN I expect them to either deal with a reaction they might not expect, or to move on, or to treat me in a way that would turn me in the way they want me to be.
I can not please everyone in changing my roleplay according to the different fantasies they have. All I could do by myself was done properly.
So coming back to the topic. Ther is no general slave training that will suit everyone and every role